NEWS / VIEWS 
MUTUAL FUNDS VIEWS
Citrus Analysis: Should you remain invested in the infrastructure funds?
Fri, Nov 02, 2012
Source : Shoaib Zaman, Citrus Interactive

Year 2004 saw the start of a new class of thematic funds which later emerged as an important category within the mutual fund industry—infrastructure funds. The significance of this category can be gauged from the fact that the combined assets under management (AUM) of the 22 funds belonging to this category currently stands at nearly Rs 12,500 crore (as on September 30, 2012).

Evolution of the category

The first infrastructure fund was launched by UTI Mutual Fund in April 2004. This fund, called UTI Basic Industries, was able to muster only Rs 62 crore at launch. In April 2006, it was rechristened UTI Infrastructure.  

Tata Mutual Fund was the next fund house to launch an infrastructure fund in December 2004. It was able to raise Rs 760 crore at launch, an impressive figure for those times.

In 2005 the third fund in this category, ICICI Prudential Infrastructure, was launched. It garnered an even higher Rs 1,423 crore at launch. This fund was benchmarked against the CNX infrastructure Index.

In July 2007 SBI Infrastructure Series 1 was launched. This was a close-ended fund which garnered Rs 3,286 crore. In the bear market of 2008, the fund fell by a humongous 60 per cent. The fund went open-ended in July 2010. Also in July 2012 the fund’s benchmark was changed from BSE 100 to CNX Infrastructure.

The bull market of 2007 was the high water mark for infrastructure funds. That year the maximum five funds were launched. Together they raised Rs 3,566 crore from investors.

In 2009, when the UPA government came back to power after the general election, investor sentiment rose to a new high. To tap this optimistic mood, Reliance AMC came out with its open-ended infrastructure fund and collected Rs 2,350 crore.  

Scheme Name

Inception Date

Corpus Raised  (Rs cr)

Benchmark Index

SBI Infrastructure

06-Jul-2007

3,286

CNX Infrastructure

Reliance Infrastructure

20-Jul-2009

2,294

BSE-100

HDFC Infrastructure

10-Mar-2008

1,608

S&P CNX 500

ICICI Pru Infrastructure

31-Aug-2005

1,423

CNX Infrastructure

Tata Infrastructure

31-Dec-2004

767

S&P CNX 500

Birla SL Infrastructure

17-Mar-2006

610

S&P CNX Nifty

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX (D)

29-Sep-2005

421

BSE Capital Goods

PineBridge Infra & Eco Reform

25-Feb-2008

383

BSE-100

Religare Infrastructure

24-Oct-2007

222

CNX Infrastructure

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX (G).

29-Sep-2005

207

BSE Capital Goods

Franklin Build India

04-Sep-2009

198

S&P CNX 500

DSPBR India T.I.G.E.R

11-Jun-2004

173

BSE-100

LIC Nomura MF Infra

24-Mar-2008

164

BSE-100

Canara Robeco Infrastructure

02-Dec-2005

143

BSE-100

IDFC Infrastructure

08-Mar-2011

93

CNX Infrastructure

UTI Infrastructure

07-Apr-2004

57

BSE-100

Taurus Infrastructure

05-Mar-2007

45

BSE-200

BOI AXA Focused Infra

05-Mar-2010

43

CNX Infrastructure

Baroda Pioneer Infrastructure

22-Jun-2010

35

CNX 100

Sahara Infra Fund-Fixed Pricing

10-Mar-2006

35

S&P CNX Nifty

Escorts Infrastructure Fund

26-Aug-2007

14

S&P CNX Nifty

L&T Infrastructure Fund

27-Sep-2007

1

S&P CNX Nifty

 

Performance

In 2011, when the markets fell (the BSE Sensex declined -24.83 per cent), infrastructure funds too took a beating. These funds bottomed out in December 2011 and have been on the upswing since then.  

Let us now turn to the past performance of these funds.

In 2005 there were only three funds in this category. That year the category average return of 53.68 was superior to the returns yielded by CNX Infrastructure 43.59 per cent.

By 2006, there were five funds in this category. The category average return (54.34 per cent) that year was lower than the return given by the CNX Infrastructure Index (55.55 per cent). That year's best performer was UTI Infrastructure Fund (61.38 per cent). The biggest laggard was the newly-launched Canara Robeco Infrastructure Fund (34.27 per cent).

In 2007 the category average return (83.32 per cent) was again lower than that of the CNX Infrastructure Index (94.44 per cent). In fact all nine funds underperformed the CNX Infrastructure. ICICI Infrastructure Fund (92.23 per cent) was the star performer that year, closely followed by Canara Robeco Infrastructure (90.27). UTI Infrastructure (71.34 per cent) was the laggard.

In 2008, the markets tanked and the CNX Infrastructure Index fell the most among the leading indexes. That year the category average return gave returns of -59.31 per cent, the CNX Infrastructure Index gave -57.40 per cent, while the Nifty gave a return of -51.84 per cent. The fund that fell the least was ICICI Infrastructure (-51.71 per cent) while the worst performer was Taurus Infrastructure (-66.04 per cent).

In the bull market of 2009, the previous year’s laggard, Taurus Infrastructure, produced the best performance (up 121 per cent). The laggard in 2009 was Escorts (49.37 per cent). The category average return for the year was 77.37 per cent, nearly double the return produced by the CNX Infrastructure Index. Among the major indices, BSE 200 gave the best return of 83.95 per cent.

In 2011 the market went through a bear phase. That year Canara Robeco Infrastructure (-20.48 per cent) was the best performer while Escorts Infrastructure (-47.72 per cent) was the worst. The category average return was -34.06 per cent, which was better than the return produced by the CNX Infrastructure Index (-38.63 per cent). Among the major indexes, the best performer that year was S&P CNX Nifty with a return of -24.68 per cent.

This year till September 30, 2012, the best-performing fund was HDFC Infrastructure: it went up by 42.13 per cent. The laggard was IDFC Infrastructure (up 14.62 per cent), launched in 2011. The category average return this year has been 31.25 per cent, which is better than the return of the CNX Infrastructure (26.01 per cent). Among the major indexes, S&P CNX 500 (35.05 per cent) has been the best performer this year.

Among the top 10 funds which have given the best returns since inception all funds were launched before 2007, the only exception being Franklin Build India Fund (which was launched in 2009).

Scheme Name

Since Inception Returns (%)

Launch Date

DSPBR India T.I.G.E.R

19.09

Jun-2004

Tata Infrastructure

14.78

Dec-2004

ICICI Pru Infrastructure

14.51

Aug-2005

UTI Infrastructure

14.39

Apr-2004

Canara Robeco Infrastructure

12.59

Dec-2005

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX (G)

9.02

Sep-2005

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX (D)

8.28

Sep-2005

Franklin Build India

7.51

Sep-2009

Birla SL Infrastructure

6.65

Mar-2006

Sahara Infra Fund-Fixed Pricing

5.02

Mar-2006

 

If one looks at the five-year returns of infrastructure funds, all the funds belonging to this category have given negative returns. The best-performing fund over this time span is Canara Robeco Infrastructure, with a return of -0.94 per cent. It is followed by ICICI Infrastructure with a return of -2.47 per cent. Over this period the CNX Infrastructure Index gave a return of -13 per cent.

 

Number of funds in the year

3

7

9

13

17

19

21

22

Scheme Name

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012*

UTI Infrastructure

57.38

61.38

71.34

-56.79

62.85

0.89

-36.66

37.18

DSPBR India T.I.G.E.R

53.75

52.61

82.25

-58.37

72.52

13.78

-32.73

38.96

Tata Infrastructure

49.90

60.53

83.70

-57.90

71.89

9.06

-34.81

36.25

ICICI Pru Infrastructure

 

58.73

92.23

-51.71

64.91

9.98

-31.09

27.55

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX

 

56.34

89.72

-62.55

87.44

5.12

-39.79

27.26

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX

 

56.50

85.44

-63.23

90.23

4.10

-40.68

27.76

Canara Robeco Infrastructure

 

34.27

90.27

-59.34

84.82

11.75

-20.48

29.85

Sahara Infra Fund-Fixed Pricing

 

 

80.77

-55.00

80.43

-0.14

-32.29

33.48

Birla SL Infrastructure

 

 

74.16

-60.64

92.48

9.75

-35.05

40.44

Taurus Infrastructure

 

 

 

-66.04

121.36

11.45

-34.07

31.88

SBI Infrastructure

 

 

 

-60.99

70.93

1.83

-33.15

22.77

Escorts Infrastructure

 

 

 

-61.33

49.37

0.93

-47.72

23.77

L&T Infrastructure

 

 

 

 

67.56

6.28

-35.50

34.06

Religare Infrastructure

 

 

 

-57.19

60.53

9.28

-29.40

26.28

PineBridge Infra & Eco Reform

 

 

 

 

87.06

9.77

-21.92

24.46

HDFC Infrastructure

 

 

 

 

91.57

15.22

-36.25

42.13

LIC Nomura MF Infra

 

 

 

 

59.42

8.35

-35.20

30.37

Reliance Infrastructure

 

 

 

 

 

-5.27

-46.05

30.25

Franklin Build India

 

 

 

 

 

11.90

-24.70

39.82

BOI AXA Focused Infra

 

 

 

 

 

 

-31.93

20.40

Baroda Pioneer Infrastructure

 

 

 

 

 

 

-35.76

22.61

IDFC Infrastructure

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

14.62

Average of category

53.68

54.34

83.32

-59.31

77.37

7.05

-33.97

31.25

Category: Benchmark

BSE Capital Goods

94.01

56.62

116.41

-65.00

95.39

9.20

-47.76

50.58

BSE-100

38.47

41.10

59.34

-55.49

80.59

15.66

-25.79

33.31

BSE-200

33.91

39.71

60.03

-56.73

83.95

16.22

-27.02

34.29

CNX 100

34.64

38.15

57.14

-53.81

78.53

17.91

-25.87

34.35

CNX Infrastructure

43.59

55.55

94.44

-57.40

35.87

-4.01

-38.63

26.01

S&P CNX 500

36.37

34.10

62.08

-57.36

83.65

14.13

-27.25

35.05

S&P CNX Nifty

36.46

39.96

54.40

-51.84

71.71

17.95

-24.68

32.37

Appendix

Different flavours of infrastructure funds

There are three more infrastructure funds but their mandate and scope are different, hence they have been mentioned separately below:

Tata Growing Economies Infrastructure: This scheme from Tata AMC, which was launched in March 2008, invests in companies belonging to infrastructure and other related sectors in the world's growing economies, including India. 

This fund has two plans. Plan A's mandate is to invest at least 51 per cent of its net assets in geographies outside India. In case of Plan B, the majority of the fund's net assets are invested in India.

The two plans also have different benchmarks. Plan A's benchmark is MSCI Emerging Market Index for 70 per cent of net assets and BSE Sensex for 30 per cent of net assets. For Plan B the benchmark is BSE Sensex for 65 per cent of net assets and MSCI Emerging Market Index for 35 per cent of net assets.

Scheme Name

1 Year

3 Years

YTD

2009

2010

2011

2012*

Tata Grow Economies Infra Fund-A(G)

8.16

4.81

17.57

70.54

8.50

-12.10

17.57

Tata Grow Economies Infra Fund-B(G)

3.45

-0.05

19.38

79.55

7.11

-25.34

19.38

CNX Infrastructure

-7.46

-9.20

20.86

35.87

-4.01

-38.63

20.86

BSE SENSEX

3.49

5.05

23.46

76.63

17.43

-24.70

23.46

S&P CNX Nifty

4.39

5.91

25.69

71.71

17.95

-24.68

25.69

Tata Indo Global Infrastructure: This fund's mandate is to invest 65-85 per cent of its portfolio in domestic securities belonging to infrastructure and related sectors. It invests 15-35 per cent of its portfolio in foreign securities.

The benchmarks for this fund are S&P CNX 500 for 65 per cent of the portfolio and MSCI World Index for 35 per cent of the portfolio. 

Based on current global economic outlook and estimates of infrastructure spending, the fund managers expect to focus on investment opportunities in Asia Pacific region (including India), Europe, Latin America and other growing economies. The portfolio of overseas securities is managed by a dedicated fund manager. While selecting the securities, the fund manager has the freedom to rely on inputs from internal research or external agencies in various geographies.

Scheme Name

1 Year

3 Years

YTD

2009

2010

2011

2012*

Tata Indo-Global Infra Fund(G)

2.18

-1.07

19.15

65.65

7.12

-25.61

19.15

CNX Infrastructure

-7.46

-9.20

20.86

35.87

-4.01

-38.63

20.86

BSE SENSEX

3.49

5.05

23.46

76.63

17.43

-24.70

23.46

S&P CNX Nifty

4.39

5.91

25.69

71.71

17.95

-24.68

25.69

Goldman Sachs Infra BeES: Launched in September 2010, Goldman Sachs Infra BeES is an exchange traded fund (ETF), which aims to provide returns, before expenses, that closely correspond to its benchmark, the CNX Infrastructure Index. A passively managed fund, its portfolio will replicate the benchmark (invest in the same companies and in the same proportion).  

Scheme Name

1 Year

SINCE INCEPTION

YTD

2011

2012*

GS Infra BeES

-7.34

-18.24

21.32

-38.64

21.32

CNX Infrastructure

-7.46

-18.25

20.86

-38.63

20.86

BSE SENSEX

3.49

 

23.46

-24.70

23.46

S&P CNX Nifty

4.39

 

25.69

-24.68

25.69

Anomaly in benchmarking

Of the 22 funds that are actively managed and invest in India, only five funds are benchmarked against CNX Infrastructure Index, the most appropriate index for this category. The other 17 funds are benchmarked against broader indexes such as BSE 100, CNX 100, S&P CNX 500 and S&P CNX NIFTY, which strikes one as anomalous. Two funds, both from the same fund house (mentioned below), are benchmarked against the BSE Capital Goods Index, a rather narrow index for benchmarking the performance of an infrastructure fund.

Six funds have benchmarked themselves against the BSE-100 Index: Canara Robeco Infrastructure Fund (G), DSPBR India T.I.G.E.R Fund (G), LIC Nomura MF Infra Fund (G), PineBridge Infra & Eco Reform Fund (G), Reliance Infrastructure Fund (G) and UTI Infrastructure Fund (D).

Taurus Infrastructure Fund (G) is the only fund which is benchmarked against BSE 200.

Baroda Pioneer Infrastructure Fund (G) is the only fund benchmarked against CNX 100.

Sundaram CAPEX is the only fund that is benchmarked against the BSE Capital Goods Index, which, as we said above, is a rather narrow index for benchmarking the performance of an infrastructure fund.  

The three funds that are benchmarked against S&P CNX 500 are Franklin Build India Fund (G), HDFC Infrastructure Fund (G), and Tata Infrastructure Fund (G).

Several infrastructure funds are benchmarked against the S&P CNX Nifty: Birla SL Infrastructure Fund (G), Escorts Infrastructure Fund (G), L&T Infrastructure Fund (G), and Sahara Infra Fund-Fixed Pricing (G).

Benchmarking an infrastructure fund against such indexes as the S&P CNX Nifty, CNX 100, BSE 100 and S&P CNX 500, which include stocks from a wide range of sectors, is also conceptually not right.

Only five funds are benchmarked against the CNX Infrastructure Index, the most appropriate benchmark for this category. These funds are BOI AXA Focused Infra Fund (G), ICICI Pru Infrastructure Fund (G), IDFC Infrastructure-A (G), Religare Infrastructure Fund (G) and SBI Infrastructure Fund-I (G).

Conceptual query

One of the biggest issues for anyone studying infrastructure funds is the exact definition of what comprises infrastructure. In fact, there are big discrepancies in the various definitions of infrastructure used by the different departments of the government: http://infrastructure.gov.in/pdf/doi.pdf .

The investment objectives of most mutual fund schemes in this category do not spell out explicitly which sectors fall within the ambit of infrastructure.

To give you a sense of the latitude that infrastructure funds enjoy, we have given the mandates of a few funds below.

DSP BlackRock India T.I.G.E.R. Fund (TIGER stands for The Infrastructure Growth and Economic Reforms): This fund enjoys the latitude to invest in Power, Banking & Finance, Telecom, Oil & Gas, Pharmaceuticals, Media, Fertilizers, Travel & Tourism, Cement, Engineering, Metals and Auto.

Sundaram-Select Thematic Funds-CAPEX’s mandate is to focus on beneficiaries of infrastructure/capex spend story in India under normal circumstances. This does not clearly state which sectors are out of bounds for the fund.

The newly launched IDFC Infrastructure states that it will buy stocks that are covered under the definition of infrastructure by RBI/World Bank.

Given below are the sectors that are constituents of the CNX Infrastructure Index.

 

CNX Infrastructure Sep-2012

Construction Project

36.42

Power

27.51

Telecom – Services

16.28

Industrial Capital Goods

12.96

Construction

4.70

Transportation

2.13

 

 
|
|
|
|
|
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
  RELATED NEWS >>